Since 1960


Thank you for visiting us today! You have landed on a page of our OLD Website and the content may be out of date.
For current products and prices, please visit  our new site by clicking on the link below:

Find something you like on our old website? When on our new website, just enter the item number in the search box to quickly locate the same item there.


search our website
shop by occasion
shop by season
shop by brand
shop new items
shop sale items
gift certificates
parish link
other links
gift registry


Join Our Email List



Papal Shop


All Safe Industrial Services Job Openings
We're always looking for great people!


Reconciliation Gifts

A - LAMINATED PRAYER CARD Features the Act of Contrition on backside. #16079 $0.59

B - RECONCILIATION STORY BRACELET Fits 6”-6.5” wrist, boxed with story card. #00030 $15.00

C - discontinued

D - discontinued

E - CHILD’S GUIDE TO RECONCILIATION A colorful guide for children on receiving the sacrament of Reconciliation for the first time. Describes the purpose and procedure of the rite and helps children approach the sacrament with true comfort and a sense of joy. Ages 5-9. Hardcover #90997 $10.95

F - RECONCILIATION HOLY BEARTM 9” long. #27937 $9.95

G - RECONCILIATION LAPEL PIN Pewter, 3/4” diameter. #13522 $1.95


Plush Embroidered Reconciliation / Penance Bear
Like the popular Beanie-Babies, this bear is sure to delight children and collectors alike! 9" long when flat on back.
(Item #07090)
SALE! NOW $4.95
While Supplies Last!

(Item #CRC) $2.29 each

25-49 tokens $2.09 each
50-99 tokens $1.99 each
100+ tokens $1.89 each

39216.jpg (18468 bytes) Sacramental Charm Bracelet
Give the keepsake a little girl can wear forever...our very own collection of sacramental charms! Choose just the cross charm for a simple statement, or begin your collection with the Baptism charm and add more as you little girl grows up. Bracelet and charms are made from sterling silver. Boxed.

Bracelet Only - 6.5" long. Gift Boxed (Item #39216) $39.95

Baptism Charm (Item #37914)
Holy Eucharist Charm (Item #37916)
Confirmation Charm (Item #37919)
$29.95 each

Miraculous Heart Charm (Item #38470) $23.95

Cross Charm (Item #38425) $23.95


 10213.jpg (45134 bytes) Penance Charm .50" tall x .38" wide. (Item #10213) $29.95
Foam Reconciliation Bookmark Class Pack
Class pack includes all pieces to make 12 bookmarks as shown
. Affordable class project! (Item #37749)
$5.95/pkg of 12
Sacrament of Reconciliation Adjustable Ring
(Item #15879) $4.95
Sacrament of Reconciliation Pendant Necklaces on Chains
Silver tone (Item #15880) $4.95
Gold tone (Item #15881) $4.95

First Penance Lapel Pin
Size: 0.8125 x 0.8125 inches. Carded as shown. (Item #13522) $1.95

Lamb with Cross Necklace
Nicely gift boxed, makes a sweet gift for first Reconciliation. (Item #16858)

Lamb with Act of Contrition Prayer Card
(Item #12392)

"New Life" Butterfly Pop with Gummie Caterpillar
These cute and delicious pops are decorated with icing and come in four delicious colorful flavors. Cherry(Red), Lemon(Yellow), Sour Apple(Green), and Wild Berry (Blue)
Each pop is decorated with a small bow and a hang tag that reads "New Life" Therefore if any man be in Christ, he is a new creature: old things are passed away; behold, all things are become new. 2 Corinthians 5:17. Each pop comes with a delicious Sour Apple flavored gummie.
(Item #25132) $2.99 each

Cross Suckers
These delicious, long lasting Cross Pops come in four delicious colorful flavors. Cherry(Red), Lemon(Yellow), Grape(Purple), and Wild Berry (Blue)
Each pop is decorated with a small bow and a hang tag that reads "Jesus Lives" with a Bible verse. Great for Easter Baskets or Party Favors!
(Item #25133) $0.99 each


Times Seven: A Bible Verse Card Game on Forgiveness
Will you be able to collect seven Bible verses by the time you’ve played your seventh round? The more cards you have left in your hand at the end of each round, the more points you get… And that’s not a good thing! 2-6 players can enjoy this card game that will help put God’s Word into your minds. 2-6 players, ages 8+
(Item #45869) $9.99

Praying with My Fingers: An Easy Way to Talk with God Praying with My Fingers: An Easy Way to Talk with God

Inspired by Pope Francis

Thank you God for loving me...thank you that you hear me when I pray.

This creative form of prayer has been around for a long time, and is often credited, especially today, to Pope Francis when he was the Archbishop of Argentina. Regardless of its origins, it is a powerful way to teach our children to pray that the Holy Father has often utilized in his ministry. 16 page boardbook for Children.
(Item #86515) $7.99



Front & Back of Card
Praying with Your Five Fingers Laminated Card
Teaching children to pray with their fingers!

Introducing our new 8 1/2 x 11, laminated prayer card, designed for pre-kindergarten through 2nd grade children, to help them learn the prayer method taught by Pope Francis. Each finger on their hand represents a people to pray for - from family and friends, to world leaders and those who are ill.

This creative form of prayer has been around for a long time, and is often credited, especially today, to Pope Francis when he was the Archbishop of Argentina. Perhaps it even existed prior to Pope Francis. Either way, it is a powerful way to pray—and to teach our children to pray—that the Holy Father has often utilized in his ministry.

This prayer card makes a perfect end of vacation bible school send off gift, a start of year gift, or a gift for First Reconciliation or First Communion.

(Item #76543) $3.25


Wood Keepsake Box from Poland
Hand carved and stained. Interior of box is lined with balsa wood. Measures 2.75" square. (Item #37851)

Sacrament Keepsake Box
Record and cherish the celebration of the sacraments in the life of your child. Roomy 10"x10"x9" lidded box is made of sturdy gloss coated pasteboard. Can hold mementoes from Baptism day, First Communion day, Reconciliation Day and Confirmation day. (Item #34357) $16.95 

Fontanini Angel with Lamb
Figure available in two sizes! 2 3/4" and 3 1/2" tall!  Polymer Resin. Great Reconciliation Gift! Gift Boxed.
2.75" (Item #33075) $16.00
5" polymer Fontanini figurine. Gift Boxed. (Item #26518) $25.00
Adina, Angel Holding Lamb
5" scale polyresin Fontanini figure. (Item #39841) $12.50
Palm Sized Wood Cross for Holding
A nice addition to your daily prayer! Handcrafted in the Holy Land from native olive wood, this cross is a tangible symbol of true hope, real comfort, and unfailing mercy of Christ who holds you. Let it direct you to be presence of Christ. This cross is made to fit comfortably in the palm of a person's hand. We hope this handmade wood cross will bring added strength and reflection to your prayer time. This cross can be given as a gift in a time of need or to enhance one's prayer life.
Small enough to become your 'cross in your pocket' or purse as well! 4" tall x 2.25" wide. (Item #04052) $21.95
OUR PRICE $12.95
Lunch Box Promises: Over 75 Tear-Out Notes with Promises from God's Word
This book is a great way to remind your child of God’s faithfulness during the school day. Each note includes a promise verse and an explanation for your child. 176 pages, paperback. (Item #81664) $7.99
Lunch Box Laughs: Over 75 Tear-Out Jokes to Make Your Child Giggle
This book will remind children that laughter is a gift from God. It is packed with colorful tear-out notes parents can pack in lunch boxes or tuck in backpacks to brighten their child’s day.
176 pages, paperback. (Item #81659) $7.99
Lunch Box Trivia: Over 75 Tear-Out Fun Facts About the Bible & Other Cool Stuff
Send your child to school with a reminder of the amazing things God created. This book is packed with colorful tear-out notes parents can pack in lunch boxes or tuck in backpacks to brighten their child’s day. 176 pages, paperback. (Item #81662) $7.99

Party Supplies & More!

You may also like:
Religious Cookie Cutter Set
Set of 6 religious designs, especially selected for First Holy Communion. Use cookies as your party dessert or decorate and wrap as favors for your guests! An economical option that’s sure to please not only your guests, but your and your child as well! Kids love hands-on projects and this would be a wonderful way for your child and you to do something together and let your creativity take over! Set of 6 plastic cookie cutters, each approximately 3.5” to 6.5” in size. Top shelf dishwasher safe.
(Item #30550) $6.95/set of 6
SALE! NOW $4.95/set of 6
While Supplies Last


Making Things Right - Revised
The Sacrament of Reconciliation

un Activities Help Children Learn Profound Truths About God's Infinite Mercy and Love

Designed for use in the classroom or at home, Making Things Right, Revised is the perfect way to help children prepare to celebrate the Sacrament of Reconciliation. Here is catechesis at its finest as, page after page, ideas and activities engage children and reinforce lessons presented by a parent or catechist.

Children are eager to ...

  • Fill in missing words
  • Draw and color illustrations
  • Match answers
  • Solve word puzzles
  • Decode messages

They learn about ...

  • God's love and mercy
  • Loving God and others
  • Sin and its effects
  • What it means to be sorry and ask for forgiveness
  • How to prepare for and celebrate the Sacrament of Reconciliation with joy

Consistent with the Catechism of the Catholic Church, Making Things Right, Revised includes material at the end of the book to enrich the faith of the parent and catechist and to help them prepare each lesson. The Parent/Catechist Guide gives an overview of each section, explains the focus of each page, and suggests ways to integrate the ideas presented into the children's own faith and life. It is no wonder that Making Things Right, Revised remains the top choice of religious educators nationwide! (Item #84182) $6.95

Additional Books:

First Reconciliation: Reproducible Activities for Young Children Item #98905 $9.95




Back ] Up ] Next ]

Baby/Baptism ] [ Reconciliation ] First Communion ] Confirmation ] R.C.I.A. ] Wedding ]


1960-2015  Copyright Catholic Supply of St. Louis, Inc. | CATHOLICSUPPLY.COM® | All Rights Reserved
Type Errors Subject to Correction

Our site is protected by VeriSign, the strongest SSL encryption available. When you enter our secure order form, be assured that we at Catholic Supply do everything in our power to keep your personal information safe. Plus, we never share your personal information with outside parties.  To view more about our privacy and security policy, please view our Privacy Policy.

visa mastercard discover american express logo

Follow us on